Berean Baptist Church from the date of its incorporation on August 11, 1850 when the influence of the Abolitionists movement prompted frequent meetings of mixed racial groups who were, by their common commitments to the Christian faith, attempting to effect spiritual and social change. The visible expression of this commitment was the organizing of this church, which later served as a way station for the "underground railroad."

In 1850, just approximately (20) doors from where Berean now stands (9) men begin to discuss the importance of the Christian faith and it's power to effect spiritual and social change. These discussions inspired Peter Balem (a white man) one of the original (9)nine to be a "doer of the Word and not a hearer only."  By donating land and lumber Mr. Balem definitely became a Berean builder. The Land was purchased on  "the hill" (2 blocks from present location) known then as Carrsville (now known as Weeksville)  An interracial congregation was organized under the pastorate of a white minister, Rev. Daniel Resse. Rev. Underdue succeeded him. Because the church was located on a hill, it was difficult for some of the members to attend.  This difficulty prompted the decision to separate the congregation. Thus, a group of white  men and women built a church on the corner of Herkimer Street near Troy Avenue.  Peter Balem was still interested in the original church.   Therefore, he granted a mortgage of  1500.00 to safeguard the financial interest of Berean. The agreement provided that the property could not be further mortgaged nor sold during the ensuing twenty- (20) year period.